What’s the BUZZ? — AI in Business
“What’s the BUZZ?” is a live format where leaders in the field of artificial intelligence, generative AI, agentic AI, and automation share their insights and experiences on how they have successfully turned technology hype into business outcomes.
Each episode features a different guest who shares their journey in implementing AI and automation in business. From overcoming challenges to seeing real results, our guests provide valuable insights and practical advice for those looking to leverage the power of AI, generative AI, agentic AI, and process automation.
Since 2021, AI leaders have shared their perspectives on AI strategy, leadership, culture, product mindset, collaboration, ethics, sustainability, technology, privacy, and security.
Whether you're just starting out or looking to take your efforts to the next level, “What’s the BUZZ?” is the perfect resource for staying up-to-date on the latest trends and best practices in the world of AI and automation in business.
**********
“What’s the BUZZ?” is hosted and produced by Andreas Welsch, top 10 AI advisor, thought leader, speaker, and author of the “AI Leadership Handbook”. He is the Founder & Chief AI Strategist at Intelligence Briefing, a boutique AI advisory firm.
What’s the BUZZ? — AI in Business
Personal Assistants: Who Owns the Customer Relationship? (Jess Graham)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Your customers are starting to send personal assistants to shop for them. The agent researches, compares, and buys, and the platform that runs it sits closer to your customer than your brand does. If the first moment a customer meets you is when your product shows up on their doorstep, what do you still own in that relationship?
In this episode of "What's the BUZZ?", host Andreas Welsch sits down with Jess Graham, Founder & CEO of Banquet, to work through what personal assistants mean for brands and who really owns the customer relationship. Jess helps brands and companies rethink marketing as agents change the funnel, with a focus on owned data, owned channels, and assets that compound over time.
Key insights from this conversation include:
- Disintermediation is not new. The rent is. Platforms have stood between brands and buyers for 20 years, and agents are the next layer. Jess sees the cost of reaching people rising while their attention gets thinner: "My perspective is that the rent is just going up."
- Own the narrative and its distribution. Brands remain the experts in their products and customers, but agents will connect signals brands have not spotted yet. Jess advises brands to own both their story and the channels that carry it, because owned surfaces compound while rented ones erode.
- Agents take the routine, humans keep the considered. Jess points to Chewy, where about 80% of purchases run on autoship. The remaining 20% is where trial, discovery, and high-stakes decisions happen, and that is where human interaction and trust still decide the sale.
- Double down on the most human moments. In B2B, that means owning the methodology, the precedent, or the category, and making the RFP response and the room presentation even more human. Probabilistic answers are not good enough where a purchase needs trust or is highly technical.
- Visibility to machines is only half the job. AEO and GEO matter because agents are now the first line of research. Jess warns that boardrooms spend most of their attention on being seen by bots and too little on where the bots are not playing, such as the unboxing experience when an agent picked your brand for the customer.
- Measure for the agent era. Jess starts every client engagement with the dashboards. If bots outnumber human visitors, unique visitors and time on site stop telling you much. Treat the marketing budget like a portfolio: rent what you need now, and build owned assets that reduce your risk over time.
What leaders can do now: review your dashboards and retire metrics that no longer reflect human buyers; map which parts of your buying process agents will own and which remain human, then invest in the human ones; give customers concrete reasons to come to your own channels, such as your app, your email list, or your site.
Jess's line to write down: "We have to give people reasons to do these things. You can't just tell them to do it."
When an agent makes the first choice for your customer, what will make them choose you the second time?
Questions or suggestions? Send me a Text Message.
***********
Disclaimer: Views are the participants’ own and do not represent those of any participant’s past, present, or future employers. Participation in this event is independent of any potential business relationship (past, present, or future) between the participants or between their employers.
Level up your AI Leadership game with the AI Leadership Handbook (https://www.aileadershiphandbook.com) and shape the next generation of AI-ready teams with The HUMAN Agentic AI Edge (https://www.humanagenticaiedge.com).
More details:
https://www.intelligence-briefing.com
All episodes:
https://www.intelligence-briefing.com/podcast
Get a weekly thought-provoking post in your inbox:
https://www.intelligence-briefing.com/newsletter
Today we'll talk about what happens when personal assistants shop on your behalf. What does it mean for you as a brand? Who actually owns the customer relationship? And I've invited a special guest to talk more about this Jess Graham. Thank you so much for joining, Jess.
Jess GrahamThank you for having me. I'm so delighted to be here and to be talking about this incredibly meaty and fast-changing topic.
Andreas WelschIsn't it? It's crazy, just the last couple weeks, the last couple months we've seen so much innovation, and I feel we're really, again at this leading edge of things, which is why I'm so excited to be having this conversation today. For those of you that are listening and watching and thinking about what, what do personal assistants mean for my business?" So we'll talk a lot about that. But Jess, maybe not everyone in the audience is familiar with you yet. Probably not maybe can you introduce yourself real quick, who you are and what you do?
Jess GrahamSure. So my name is Jess. I own a company called Banquet. We help brands and companies think about marketing differently. Certainly technology is really changing how consumers buy and find things, how businesses buy and find things, and we believe that consumers and brands, and companies need to be thinking a lot about how agents are changing the funnel, how how technology is changing consumer behavior, and how consumers think about making purchases, and how companies should think about building assets that compound for them over time own their data, and create channels that they can build direct relationships with their customers and their prospects and their potential clients.
Andreas WelschHuh. Sounds like you're gonna have your hands full for the next couple years.
Jess GrahamOne would think. One would think.
Andreas WelschYeah. Hey, I've been building my own agentic system that helps me run my business in different aspects of it. But now looking at how Muse, how Dots how others are- helping us accomplish more, especially as consumers. I've been thinking a lot more about, again what does it mean if you're on the other end, because it seems that the likes of OpenAI and Meta and those are a lot closer to the customer than you and your brand might be. And last year al- already we saw OpenAI experiment with checkout in ChatGPT, and it c- Walmart was one of their early partners, but they quickly changed how this, this whole thing worked and said, "Hey, we, we need to own that, that customer relationship." What are some of the learnings and maybe some more context that you've seen there- Yeah when, yeah, when, when- So- o- OpenAI own- owns that relationship, for example?
Jess GrahamYeah, I think disintermediating relationships is nothing new. Technology has been doing that for years. For the last 20 years platforms like Meta and Amazon and Walmart, and even to some extent Visa, my old employer get in between a brand and its ultimate either consumer or buyer on the B2B side. And as platforms have pl- proliferated whether that's social media platforms or aggregation platforms or content platforms, those platforms have created a lot of power. They have a lot of power to command pretty significant rent for eyeballs. And- My perspective is that the rent is just going up. The eyeballs of the people that are there, whether they're business owners or consumers, are starting to be a little bit more vacant. And we've got a bunch of players on the scene like Meta, like Walmart, who have launched agents and know a lot about consumer behavior, right? I also used to work at Meta, and I used to work at Instagram, and I understand just how amazing their data is on consumer behavior. I think brands will continue to be the experts in their product, their services, their target consumers. But I think that these agents are going to be very good at connecting the dots between the brands and the consumers, between behaviors that brands haven't yet recognized as potential buying factors or signal, and things that these platforms can see more readily as signal or buying triggers. So I think we are in for a really wild ride, but I think the question of who owns the consumer is really important. And arguably, brands' ability to own their consumer has really changed over time, and not necessarily in a positive way for brands as these platforms have really gathered more momentum. So my suggestion for brands is always to figure out how they can own their narrative directly to their consumer or directly to the business buying them. And usually that comes through really having ownership, not just with the narrative, but how that narrative is distributed.
Andreas WelschThat's interesting. O- over the last few episodes, we've talked more about what happens when the agent is a buyer, how do you advertise them to them how does paid social change, and all, all these kind of things.
Jess GrahamYeah.
Andreas WelschBut is the conclusion right then to say if you are a brand, you should try to get the consumer as quickly as possible off that agentic platform and onto your properties so you have more leverage, so you have even more data points and more insights?
Jess GrahamI think that's the name of the game. I think that brands who are gonna win in the future have got to figure out how they can build some coalition with each other, right? I think that the way in which brands in the future potentially compete against these really large platforms that are taking as much as 60 cents for every revenue dollar they collect is to create their own systems of record, their own platforms and surface areas where people can discover them and have brand experiences with them that are meaningful. I think, if you think about the B2B space, I think about the install being the place where you have the most ability as a brand to influence the positive notion and belief and experience that a business or a consumer has with you. I think about, lawyers or professional services firms really needing to own the outcomes or the precedent, right? So every category is gonna be a bit different, but I do think that There are places in every category where business owners, brands, companies should be doubling down, places where agents aren't going to be able to tread as easily or as well because there's a trust structure that needs to be there. Probabilistic isn't good enough. It needs to be deterministic or the purchase is highly technical or really considered. So I think those are some of the... I think companies should be thinking about the category that they're in and where they can really win in terms of the conversation, ongoing dialogue, experience with the brand, and doubling down in those areas because the rented platforms, not only do they seem to be in collapse, meaning there's less trust, there's more AI slop, there's more grift, there's more cost, there's less trusted influencers and those kinds of things but they also lose a lot of control as a brand going through those going through those channels. So I think places where you can exert more control and have more ownership are places that compound for you over time as opposed to the rented ones.
Andreas WelschSo you said brands should create unique brand experiences and they should own those experiences. It sounds like a plea for more human interaction when- I- do the discovery and maybe click the button. Is that kind of where this is going? Yeah.
Jess GrahamI think... So I think about Chewy a lot as a business and as a brand. So Chewy reports that 80% of what gets bought on their platform is auto-saved, so auto-shipped. That is a pretty... I- they've worked really hard for those metrics. That was their business objective when they started, and they really realized it. But the other 20% is where most of us get a lot of dopamine. It's where brands get a lot of trial and experimentation. It's where both people and brands discover new things about each other and new new entrants, new features, new benefits new things to try. So I think it's... I think the reality is in agentic commerce, we're moving more and more to things that we would all maybe s- consider drudgery to be automated, to be simpler, to be less challenging, to be faster, cheaper, better. But then there's a whole category of things that both businesses and consumers buy where there's a lot more consideration that has to go into it, and there is a lot more human interaction that has to go into it perhaps. So I do think we are gonna be living in a world that gets a bit more bifurcated before it, it gets more similar, where there will be things that are very clearly things that we send out for agents and feel very comfortable with that. But I think things that are really high ticket, really high risk, h- high reward, things that are new for us or that we don't feel expert in there's gonna be whole categories of spend that don't adjust very well to agents. And that's the, the sort of f- first last frontier I think is those kinds of purchases.
Andreas WelschThat makes a lot of sense. A lot of the financial, legal decisions, b- big- Exactly big ticket purchases- Exactly that's where you want to have that personal relationship usually or-
Jess GrahamExactly
Andreas WelschI think a big part of it is trust that comes in.
Jess GrahamAbsolutely.
Andreas WelschToo,
Jess Grahamabsolutely.
Andreas WelschYeah. Now how can businesses then retain that ownership? There has to be more than o- own the experience or... A couple weeks ago, s- Mars Snickers ran- Yep. Yep a campaign and if you need to give your AI assistant a break, copy this. There's blah, blah, blah into it, and then it fetches some data and says, "Now I'm chewing on my Snickers." Great. But how, how-
Jess GrahamGimmicky
Andreas Welschr- yes. How else can B2B brands own that relationship?
Jess GrahamI think if you're a B2Bra- B brand, it depends on what category you're in. Like I said, I think that there are... If you are a professional services firm, you wanna own the precedent, you wanna own the methodology, you wanna own something that is really significant. You wanna own the category the way Kleenex owns the category. You are the stated arbiter of the service, the product, the benefit, the feature, right? I think that you want to double down in the parts of the procurement process that feel the most human and make them even more human. So whether that's the, how you answer the RFP, how you present in the room, how you think about the information and how it's presented. Certainly we're doing a lot of that as it relates to schema markup and, data presentment of product tables and all of that. But I think there's still a human in most of those loops, especially if we're talking about large B2B procurement and large enterprise deals and other things. I think like consumers and like the rest of us, we're gonna get very good at parsing what the machines can do and what they do really well, and what they do fast and what they do cheap. And then this layer of things that we need to look somebody in the whites of their eyes, we need to experience it for ourselves, we need to talk to another human and see how their experience was. We need to do some pattern recognition or some mapping. But I do think there is this, there is an entire element that is still very human. We need to figure out for our category what that is and really lean into it and give people reasons to talk to us regularly. Give us, give them reasons to give them our phone number, give them our email address go to a particular website, leverage our app, right? We have to give people reasons to do these things. You can't just tell them to do it. So it's a combination of sort of the best of marketing for millennia, right? It's not super different in those ways. We just get to hopefully steer a bunch of work that is lower value add to automation, which would be grand.
Andreas WelschWouldn't it? Like
Jess Grahamthat.
Andreas WelschYes. Especially if it works, and if it works consistently. Yes.
Jess GrahamYes. Yes.
Andreas WelschThat, that would be even better, especially when we start handing those things our credit cards.
Jess GrahamYes. Absolutely. But I was... it's interesting 'cause I was at Visa in the 2000s, and I watched people go from having a lot of hesitation for, to put their credit card number into a, a, a website, into an address. There were huge swaths of people who wouldn't do that. By the time I left Visa nine years later, which, today feels like an eternity and a lifetime, and in some ways when I was working there it did too, but that's another story. But the reality is that nine years to have that kind of consumer behavior where we went from a very significant part of the por- population really not trusting entering their credit card number into an internet website- and using their phone to pay for it every time they go through a turnstile at the subway in New York that is quite a dramatic consumer change that, you know I would argue that one of the reasons we got there was because there was a coalition called Visa that actually talked to consumers all the same way and talked to businesses all in the same way and got that consumer shift to happen. There are lots of opportunities for other brands and categories and businesses to do that, but we don't do that very well in this country. But I would argue that huge consumer shift required billions of dollars and- Yeah 10 years of time.
Andreas WelschYes.
Jess GrahamWe're gonna need the same kinds of real structure and focus and bringing the best of everything to bear to get consumers to do what we want them to do- or businesses to do what we want them to do in the sales process. It's just part of life. We have to educate consumers to get them to do what we want. We... It's just what happens. It's just what we have to do.
Andreas WelschTo me, what you said i- is something I keep coming back to as well a, a lot of times, and it is that change does take time even though we're- Yes w- we're seeing rapid change- Yes massive change- Yeah with a lot of uncertainty, but just rushing into it blindly is not going to deliver the results that you're expecting to get out of it if you don't give it- Yes the time. Yes it's also a little bit of a, a tug of war between how much time do I give and how much time do I have to a- adapt.
Jess GrahamI think a lot about that when people approach me and ask what to do about AEO and GEO and some of those, those sort of tactics. I think there are a lot of people who are really focused on being visible to machines, which I think is incredibly important. These are the first line of research now. They are Google search effectively, right? It's an incredibly important place to play. But I think if you focus all of your time and energy and effort in being visible and findable by machines, you forget that there are humans still in the loop, very much so these days. And the fact that, we are the ones training these machines, right? And so keeping close to what the consumers still actually want and need and how we think about making decisions is still so relevant and still so important. And one of the things that I think is really challenging is the conversation that's happening in most boardrooms and in most C-suites, which is, like, all about this agentic visibility thing and how do we get seen by the bots, and not nearly enough time and money and attention to the other part of that equation, which is, like, where are the bots not playing? Where... what are we needing to own in this value chain that we either didn't have an opportunity to own before or that is more important than it was before? The unboxing experience is another great example. If we're living in an age where evaluation is compressed to a prompt, and the marketing funnel is no longer a funnel that gets somebody to become aware of you, consider you, and then purchase you, if that has shrunk, and we're experiencing a flip of that, so my first interaction potentially with a brand is when it shows up on my doorstep or shows up as an install on my, browser, that has to do a very different job than it did before, right? And so I think about- I think about those experiences, the human ones, and we're back to that again, but the unboxing, it has to do a very different job. If you didn't actually ask for Marvis whitening toothpaste, you just asked for a really good whitening toothpaste- Right and Marvis ends up on your doorstep, Marvis has to determ- you know, Marvis has to make you a brand advocate, not just in the experience of the product, hopefully, but also in, in the interaction with the brand when it shows up on the doorstep- and on the packaging and all that stuff.
Andreas WelschNow does that then lead to brands having their own agents that talk to your personal agent- Sure that talk to other agents and agents, or-
Jess GrahamAbsolutely, yes. I don't know what it's gonna look like. I don't... I, it's gonna be a total mess. But yeah, I think everyone's building agents because a- agents are, with orchestrators, they are controlling who goes where, who's presented who's in the, who's in the shortlist, right? I think everybody is working on agents because everybody wants their point of view, their data, their brand, their decision-making, their, checkout process to win. So remains to be seen, but everybody's building one, so they're all gonna be talking to each other. It'll be really interesting to hear their conversations.
Andreas WelschYay. Now, hey, earlier you said ob- obviously the big brand big brands already have a lot of consumer data. They have a lot of consumer behavior information over years and decades. Now, when we all started with ChatGPT and Claude, these tools were helpful to some extent, but they weren't necessar- necessarily great, and they weren't necessarily great because they didn't know a lot about us. So vendors added- Context a- and added memory, added context. Yeah. Now we don't need to tell it every time, "I'm Andreas, I do HC-" Yeah. or I'm Jess." Thank
Jess GrahamGod.
Andreas WelschThat's awesome. But we also know that the more context these tools have, typically the better the recommendations get. Yeah. So what does that then mean for personal a- assistance? How much data do we need to give them to become useful, and is that a gift or is that a curse if they know ourselves better than- It's such a- than we know?
Jess GrahamIt's such a good question, right? Like- So the only thing that I can come back to is shopping, and sorry to go there, but that's just where I'm gonna go. The things in my wardrobe, my personal wardrobe that I get the most compliments on when I'm out in the world, and let's face it, wardrobe and styling for some of us is the place where are putting yourself out there to, to be commented on and to reflect back your ethos, your values, whatever. It's a very highly personal th- part of belonging, right? So most of the things in my wardrobe that get the most... And I like th- the things in my wardrobe that get like people to like kinda look up and, like the things that are a little bit wild. It's part of my personality There's almost nothing in... if I think about my closet, there's almost nothing in my closet that I love to wear that gets the most comments that any agent would have served up to me. The green sweater with the tigers on it that literally I cannot leave the house and not get comments about, 'cause it's a great fucking sweater. I never would have bought that unless I had been walking down a row of shops in Baltimore with my niece, and out of the corner of my eye just happened to see this amazing sweater with this great pattern, and I ran in and bought one for me and bought one from her. There's no agent in the world, there's no prompt that I'm gonna a- Yeah that I'm gonna put into a machine that says, "Bu- I'm looking for a green acrylic sweater th- with a V-neck, with three buttons, that..." It's just not a prompt, right? And so that's the kind of stuff that feels like it's going to get whittled away that makes me worried. And we know that in order to discover things, truly discover things, we need some agency. We need some surprise.
Andreas WelschYeah.
Jess GrahamAnd those are things that we can't really engineer. We can try, and we have tried to engineer delight and other things, and we can do some of it, but not all of it. And I think it... when we lose those outliers and those edges, we become much less interesting people. We become much less interesting consumers. We become less interesting brands. It all gets a lot less interesting. So- So I think sometimes too much data we think we know, but even with all the data in the world, you wouldn't have predicted the green sweater with the tigers.
Andreas WelschYes. Yeah. So- goes back to the whole discussion about the mean. We're all gravitating towards the mean, and we're losing the outliers like you said.
Jess GrahamIt's that Beigeville thing, right? And what's really interesting to me is having worked at Facebook and Instagram and so much of the discourse was about how social media polarizes us, right? And it does. It absolutely does. It's so polarized us, we're all in our own little bubbles. And now we've got agentic stuff that's forcing everyone into the middle, right? We've got this sort of like we don't have culture of any kind. Everyone's an island to themselves. Everybody is their own brand. Everybody's their own individual thing, and that's certainly true in the US because it's part of our ethos- Yeah and our values and all the things, right? But then there's this other piece where- Where you lose so much nuance in LLMs that it becomes, uninteresting sometimes. And so that's the... we were talking before we started recording can you tell that what someone's written is authentic and real and, or is it, has it been written by a bot, it's a question.
Andreas WelschYeah. So we talked a lot about the consumer side and what it will likely- Yeah mean for us as, as consumers. Now if we- Yeah look at the other side of that coin- Indeed and we say, what does it mean for businesses? What's your recommendation? How should business leaders get started? You said yes to some some GEO, AEO, but don't only focus there.
Jess GrahamDon't...
Andreas WelschYeah. What are some of the other recommendations you have so your business shows up in agentic results, gets considered is easy to work with for personal assistants, but still doesn't l- lose the human element?
Jess GrahamSo one of the things that I recommend a couple things to clients, and the first thing I do with clients is I look at all their dashboards. Because you, what you measure matters. We've always said that, right? I think most of the time we talk about measurement, we talk about what doesn't get measured doesn't get actioned. But the reverse is also true. When you start measuring things, there is momentum inherent that you need to action it, and a lot of our dashboards were created 10 years ago, 15 years ago, even five years ago, hell, even five minutes ago seems irrelevant right now, right? Yeah. And so one of the things that I do with clients first is let's take a look at what you're measuring. Are you measuring unique website visitors? Because if you are, that's probably not interesting. Are you managing for time on site? 'Cause if so, I'm not sure that really matters that much either. If Google is sending five bots for every one pair of human eyeballs, let's rethink how- you use this surface and th- this space. So we start with what we're measuring, and then we start thinking about what the agent, we- what we want the agents to own, and what we want the agents not to own. Where we still think there is, in the procurement process, in the dec- decision-making process, where are the most human parts of that, and how do we lean into them? What questions are our clients or prospects routinely asking us where we could deliver something back that felt more personalized than a product sheet? What what can we leverage in terms of technology to build as an experience that gives people more of an understanding of what it means to be a customer, right? Like, how do we get them past their barriers more quickly or more easily with technology? My advice is, you look at what you're doing, you look at what you're measuring, you look at your KPIs, you look at the places that can maintain the most human, elements. And then you look at the places where the machines are truly taking over, where it's mostly price and availability, and you make decisions like that. And the other thing that I tell clients to do is, think about how you invest the way you would your assets in a portfolio. I don't think enough marketers think this way, but the way that I've always thought about my marketing budgets is like an asset allocation. It's like, how do you... How do I think about risk? Where's my risk? Where's my ownership of the customer? How can I mitigate the risk? How can I build over time? M-, rent things that I, I need immediately, but, put a trajectory in place that I can actually build the things that I'm renting so that, that- that they're eventually ready and willing for me. But I think most of it is thinking about that Chewy example of there's 80% that's gonna be on autoship. It's the 20- it's the other 20%. Every business has that 80/20%, right? It's a pretty common rule at this point. Specifically as it rates, relates to this, that's what I would be thinking about, is what are you actually measuring, and what's actually actionable these days, and what do you wanna action? And what are the most human and most machine-driven parts? And really double down appropriately for both of them.
Andreas WelschAwesome. Sounds like a, a very good starting point if you're wondering, what should I do now that we have personal agents, that we see more and more of our customers use agents doing business with other agents. Yeah. How do we stay discoverable, but also how do we stay human? That's the, the essence of what I'm taking away from our conversation.
Jess GrahamYeah. I would say that's a pro- probably the... my thesis overall is, there's lots and lots of things that machines can do for us, and we are, in many ways lucky to be living in an age where, we get to delegate a lot of things and not have to do them ourselves. But there are still elements of what we do that, that would be really hard for the bots to replicate, and we wouldn't want them to. The things that give us, deliver dopamine, for example. I think all the optimization culture has l- led to a lot of dopamine being shaken out of the system, and I'm a person who really likes dopamine So I might hopefully put some more back in.
Andreas WelschSounds good. Awesome. Jess, thank you so much for sharing your perspective with us. What a real pleasure having you on and learning from you- Yeah what you're seeing at this time when personal assistants are maybe taking away the consumer relationship, but there are good reasons and good ways not to let that happen, so good.
Jess GrahamExactly. Love it. Thank you so much, Andreas. What a great conversation.